Now most of us have seen the opening episode of the new series, I've been checking out what other fans think. There's a few spoilers in this so if you haven't seen it yet go and watch it.
While most of the professional critics, broadly speaking give it a thumbs up, a lot of the self appointed experts on all things Who are a little more reserved on their judgement.
Well, as a medieval monk, John Lydgate once famously said, '.. you can't please all the people all the time', and while I can't begin to address the self appointed experts' concerns, I think that for me, regardless of whether elements of effects or story etc. are good or bad there must be a lead actor in the role who I feel is right.
I do confess I really did enjoy the opening episode and was keen to see Peter Capaldi's interpretation of The Doctor. As I've said in previous posts my personal preference is to see an older actor play the part, and found 'Matty watty' Smith's antics quite juvenile. Obviously, his tenure as The Doctor appealed to a lot of fans, especially female ones it would seem who, quite bizarrely, found him attractive! The same people probably felt the same about David Tennent. They may well have felt the same about Christopher Eccleston, I don't know.
So,on to yesterday's story. Regeneration episodes I've seen over the years are usually a little chaotic as everyone tries to find their feet, and 'Deep Breath' was no exception. There was a few things I found a bit dodgy. Returning character Madame Vastra who's able to wander through Victorian London clearly accepted by the Victorian public as someone who has a rather nasty facial disfigurement. I suppose if you've got the Elephant man, a crime-fighting lesbian lizard ninja is a stroll in the park.
Clara, quite naturally looked a bit confused. Her young dashing Doctor had turned into an old senile Scotsman before her eyes. But after Matty Watty's Doctor phoned her from the past, it all became totally clear to what she had to do - and, no doubt to all the Matty Watty fans who were mourning his passing. I'm not sure why we had to endure this daft cameo as I've every confidence in Peter eventually making the role his own.
And to the star, Peter Capaldi. As I said before regeneration stories are there to experiment with the character. Things haven't quite fallen into place yet as Peter's Doctor begins to form. There were comic moments.
Doctor: "I'm going to have to relieve you of your pet"
Coach Driver: "You're what?
Doctor: "Shut up, I was talking to the horse!"
In fact The Doctor told quite a few people to shut up throughout the episode. Will this be a plot point in a future episode, we'll have to wait and see. Seriously, there was a few intriguing story points that will develop into part of the story arc - the Doctor's choice of face for instance.
There was the usual 'Doctor to the rescue moment, as he ripped off his disguise, a mask made of skin, to save Clara from certain death at the removable hand of the baddie.
And finally to the baddies themselves, described by the Doctor as 'The Rubbish Robots from the Dawn of Time'. They were first seen in the David Tennent episode,
The Girl in the Fireplace, a particular favourite of mine.
Actually they looked pretty good to me, quite scary, and their leader, the grotesque Half-Face Man was very effective, visually. Although to be fair the most disturbing scene was the ninja lizard woman giving a full open mouth kiss to her 'wife' under the guise of first aid!
Actually, I do make these comments with, my tongue firmly in my cheek. Its not easy to put together a mega popular show like this and there's a lot of time, work and effort gone into it to get it right.
I'm sure Peter Capaldi has the abillities and talent to be a popular choice, and I'm wishing him and team around him all the best - and lets not forget, next week's episode features Daleks!