Watched 1972's SILENT RUNNING this weekend. I think I saw it years ago - basically the Earth's last eco-systems are shepherded in domes through space first legally then not. I enjoyed the first half immensely - the humans' interaction, the order to destroy the eco-domes, the ensuing struggle. Bruce Dern is excellent as the fanatical eco-warrior and the three small droids are prescient of Star Wars 5 years later. The film raises the question of whether Widlife is more important than Human life at a time when environmentalism was in it's infancy and more confrontational than today but still very topical, probably moreso. Dern's quick despatching of his three fellow co-workers is harsh leaving him solely in charge of the last dome in existence. He suffers brief remorse for his crimes but overall the murders are glossed over. More effort is put into his relationship with the 3 droids, well acted by double-amputee actors. The second half of the film, where Dern is alone in the dome with said Droids is rather like watching grass grow literally and I imagine modern cinema audiences would find it boring. More than the obvious eco-pocalypse motif, for me the most interesting aspect of the film is it's portrayal of an astronaut's extreme solitude and insidious descent into oblivion, both mentally and spatially, a theme hinted at in its ambiguous title and touched on in other movies: 1968's 2001, Solaris in the same year, 1979's Alien, 1997's Event Horizon and last year's brilliant Moon by Duncan Jones, son of one David Bowie. Sensationalised for the cinema no doubt, the question of the effects of isolation in space is critical to long-stay astronautics and our vision to go to Mars. What does anyone else think?
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteMoon by Duncan Jones is a great movie!
ReplyDeleteAnd the special effects are back to the actual scale models like the "old school" movies of which you spoke in your post! :)
its an odd film in that it is pretty bleak in places, but apart from the beautiful Valley Forge, what I remember most poignantly is the moment when one of the droids, is lost during a repair and Dern needs to tell the remaining two. Its one of the first instances of robots being completely mechanistic and yet showing genuine emotion.
ReplyDeleteQuote: "a time when environmentalism was in it's infancy and more confrontational than today".
ReplyDeleteEven more confrontational that today? The mind boggles.
All that and Joan Baez too!
ReplyDeleteThe queen of the flower children! See you at Woodstock! Just 5 years later and space films changed forever with Star Wars and then darkened to black with Alien. No sign of hippydom there! Just creepy music and acid blood! Industrialization!
ReplyDeleteDuncan Jones said this film was one of his inspirations for Moon, so any resemblance is more than coincidental.
ReplyDeleteYeah, definitely one of the most interesting things about the story is how well it conveys that whole sense of isolation and boredom. In real life that's going to be the biggest aspect of any manned space travel…but it's the part that almost always gets left out for the sake of action. I understand they don't want to put the audiences to sleep, but SF films go too far the other way now, afraid to have a single moment of quiet or calm or silence. (Compare the first Star Wars film to the last one, you know?)
Silent Running and 2001 both could have been drawing on the experience of commercial sailors at sea for months on end aboard a cargo ship; that might not be a bad model to copy from.
I don't know Woodsy, I always thought that Brett brought a touch of "easyrider hippiness" to "Alien"... looked to me like he had smoked some premium weed (at least) in his time!
ReplyDeleteNot to mention the Alien's "acid blood"!
I know that's groanworthy ;)
I totally agree with RAB
ReplyDeleteI'm with RAB too. All too often we see spaceflight depicted as if it's like driving down to the local shops on a quiet Sunday afternoon.
ReplyDeleteMaybe there are others, but the only TV instance suggesting real time passes is in the Castor and Pollux episode of Monbase 3. Anyone remember that?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moonbase_3